Showing posts with label thirdhand smoke. Show all posts
Showing posts with label thirdhand smoke. Show all posts

Wednesday, October 8, 2014

More Third-Hand Nicotine Nonsense: From Vapor?



Nicotine can be detected in a chamber after releasing vapor directly from an e-cigarette, according to a report in Nicotine and Tobacco Research (abstract here) by Roswell Park Cancer Institute investigators.  A Carl Phillips parody of the abstract (here) convinced me to review the journal article.  Clive Bates also published a scathing critique (here).

Dr. Maciej Goniewicz and collaborator Lily Lee released e-cig vapor from 100 4-5 second puffs into a 12 x 10 x 9 foot room.  Meticulous collection of samples revealed that about 205 micrograms of nicotine were spread out over 81 square feet of tile floor.  This is unsurprising, as most of the nicotine in vapor is expected to eventually fall to earth.  Far less nicotine was recovered from vertical surfaces like walls and windows. 

As Phillips noted, a huge amount of vapor was involved in this test, and it was injected directly into the room without passing through a user.  Even so, Phillips notes in his parody, “this means someone would have to lick clean the entire surface of a sliding glass door in order to get a dose of nicotine similar to smoking half a low-nicotine cigarette.”  Or, Phillips might have said, one would have to lick about two thirds of the 120 square foot floor. (Recovery from a vertical surface is about one fourth that of the floor.)

Four years ago, I reported that third-hand smoke is an almost imaginary vector by which smokers expose everything and everyone to dangerous toxins (here).  Today, smokeless tobacco users are also the scare campaign’s targets.  According to a 2013 study in Nicotine and Tobacco Research, “children living with smokeless tobacco users may be exposed to nicotine and other constituents of tobacco via contact with contaminated dust and household surfaces.”  (abstract here).  In this scenario, a child could consume 20 micrograms of nicotine, about one tenth the amount of the vapor floor-licker, by eating about one ounce of dust.

For Goniewicz and Lee, the exposure to nicotine from e-cigarettes is important because of “potential risks of thirdhand exposure to carcinogens formed from nicotine released from e-cigarettes.” This is reminiscent of reports that U.S. paper currency is contaminated with cocaine (here) or heroin, morphine, methamphetamine and PCP (here).  That issue was put into perspective by Adam Negrusz of the University of Illinois at Chicago (here): “I never think about this as a source of danger. We have more things which can be potentially harmful.”

Third-hand nicotine harmful?  Don’t even think about it.

Thursday, February 25, 2010

Thirdhand Smoke Cancer Hysteria


The anti-tobacco extremists’ motto: if you can measure it, it must be deadly. Last week, a group of chemists and toxicologists published a largely theoretical study claiming that “infants and children are particularly at risk” from thirdhand smoke. The first author was Mohamad Sleiman; another, James Pankow, claimed several weeks ago that smokeless tobacco users were overdosing on wintergreen flavor.

The report appeared in the Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences, a scientific journal that usually publishes solid research studies. Not this time.

Sleiman claims that nicotine residues in thirdhand smoke, which can become attached to skin, dust and items in houses or cars, can react with nitrous acid, which is formed by unvented combustion appliances (such as a gas cooktop) and smoking. The reaction produces NNK, which is a tobacco-specific nitrosamine (TSNA) that is considered a cancer-causing agent.

The report is largely theoretical, since it is very difficult to isolate and measure tiny levels of these chemical agents. For example, Sleiman estimated that smoking might expose human skin to as much as 15 nanograms of NNK per SQUARE METER. Keep in mind that a square meter is about 9 square feet. This is about 5 times the surface area of a normal adult. He also estimated that about 15 nanograms of NNK could be present over 9 square feet of furniture surfaces.

A nanogram is one billionth of a gram, and a gram is less than 4 hundredths of an ounce. So we are talking about vanishingly small amounts.

Sleiman didn’t discuss how infants and children could actually consume a 15 nanogram dose of NNK from that 9 square foot surface. He collected the residue by using special solvents, including methanol, so uptake by humans is likely to be very inefficient, perhaps negligible.

But let’s assume for a moment that a person is exposed to, and completely consumes, Sleiman’s dose of 15 nanograms of NNK every day for decades. What potential cancer-causing effect might this have?

The answer might come from what we know about NNK in a product used by millions of American men -- smokeless tobacco. In 2003, I published a study reporting the level of NNK in American moist snuff. I found that a typical 1-can per day user may be exposed to one thousand times more NNK, about 15-30 micrograms (actual consumption is probably far lower). Readers of this blog know that there is very little evidence that lifelong use of smokeless tobacco is associated with any cancer.

I am not the only tobacco researcher who is critical of the Sleiman study. Even Steven Hecht, a Minnesota professor who holds extreme positions with respect to smokeless tobacco, has doubts: “I personally feel that exposure by this route would be minimal…”

How harmful is thirdhand smoke? It probably carries about as much risk as third hand rain.

Friday, February 19, 2010

The Invention of Thirdhand Smoke


Last year, Massachusetts pediatrician Jonathan Winickoff and his colleagues invented the notion of “thirdhand smoke,” which they defined as “residual tobacco smoke contamination that remains after the cigarette is extinguished.” Winickoff described thirdhand smoke as particles and volatile compounds that cover every surface of a smoker’s home, exposing people to toxic agents for “days, weeks or months.”

Winickoff sought to prove the existence of thirdhand smoke. He analyzed a survey of about 1,500 American adults called the "Social Climate Survey of Tobacco Control"; he described this as “an annual cross-sectional survey that was designed to operationalize the concept of the social climate on tobacco into a comprehensive set of quantifiable social and environmental indicators across social institutions that characterize society.” In plain English: “a survey designed to demonize tobacco and its users in every facet of society.” Winickoff published his results in the journal Pediatrics.

Survey participants were asked whether they agreed with this statement: “Breathing air in a room today where people smoked yesterday can harm the health of infants and children.” Six out of ten participants agreed, so Winickoff declared thirdhand smoke a reality.

Winickoff was brazenly honest about why this “notion” or “concept” (his words) was developed. “Emphasizing that thirdhand smoke harms the health of children may be an important element in encouraging home smoking bans. Health messages about thirdhand smoke contamination could be easily incorporated into current tobacco control campaigns, programs, and routine clinical practice.”

I have described the evolution of thirdhand smoke from a notion to an established fact. It gets worse. Next week I’ll describe a new, largely hypothetical toxicology study claiming that nicotine residues in thirdhand smoke are being theoretically transformed into dangerous chemicals.