Showing posts with label cigarette smoking risks. Show all posts
Showing posts with label cigarette smoking risks. Show all posts

Monday, January 24, 2022

Facts About Safer Smoke-Free Products Are “Somewhere,” But Not at the FDA

 

I recently came upon the FDA website “Nicotine is Why Tobacco Products Are Addictive.”  The section “What Makes Tobacco Use Harmful” starts with partially truthful information: “Nicotine is what keeps people using tobacco products. However, it’s the thousands of chemicals contained in tobacco and tobacco smoke that make tobacco use so deadly.” [emphasis in original].

That’s not too bad, although agency officials know that the thousands of deadly chemicals are present only in smoke, not tobacco.  Then they get more specific. 

“Combustible products, or products that burn tobacco, are the most harmful. An example of a combustible product is cigarettes, which deliver more than 7,000 chemicals along with nicotine that makes it hard to quit.

“FDA-approved nicotine replacement therapies (NRTs), such as gums and lozenges, are the least harmful.”

Then it gets awful, as the guidance turns to noncombustible, or smoke-free tobacco products.

“Noncombustible products, such as heat-not-burn tobacco products, smokeless tobacco, and e-cigarettes, fall somewhere in between combustible products and NRTs.”

Somewhere?

The FDA has hundreds of scientists on staff and has funded research by thousands more at universities across America.  This federal agency is responsible for regulating the entire tobacco industry, and it sets precedents for tobacco regulation worldwide.  It claims to act only on the basis of hard science, yet it feigns ignorance about where the risks fall for smoke-free products.

This farcical position is undermined elsewhere on the webpage where the agency acknowledges that “many studies suggest e-cigarettes and noncombustible tobacco products may be less harmful than combustible cigarettes.” 

Those studies do more than suggest.  Britain’s Royal College of Physicians has stated for years that smoke-free products are at least 95% less hazardous than cigarettes – a fact that anti-tobacco zealots consistently ignore.  The FDA’s response is always “more research is needed,” though for this agency, there will never be enough.  Regulators know the facts, but they refuse to share them with smokers and their loved ones as smoker deaths continue to mount.

 

 

Tuesday, October 19, 2021

More Bad Behavior from Journal Authors & Editors on A Fatally Flawed Study of Vaping & COPD


Following is another example of junk science published by anti-tobacco crusaders, abetted by negligent journal editors.

The journal Tobacco Induced Diseases on April 7 published an article by Emine Bircan and colleagues at the University of Arkansas.  They claimed that e-cigarette use “is associated with increased odds of self-reported asthma, COPD, and [asthma-COPD overlap syndrome] among never combustible cigarette smokers.” In their abstract, the authors assert that “the age of those at risk in our study was 18–24 years.” 

First, take a look at the chart.  It is axiomatic that COPD is mostly seen in current and former smokers age 55+ years.  Now look at Bircan’s vapers in the last column: the distribution is completely upside down! This led me to examine the article in greater detail, whereupon I discovered numerous obvious errors.

Since the journal prohibits submissions from industry-funded scientists (my research is supported by unrestricted grants to the University of Louisville from tobacco companies), the only avenue to attempt to correct the errors was to write the authors directly.  I exchanged numerous emails with corresponding author Mohammed Orloff and journal editor James Scott over the period April 22 – May 12. Copies of this correspondence are available here.

In addition to raising the issue of young adults with COPD, I listed these significant errors:

1. There were two obvious wrong numbers of never cigarette smokers.

2. The inaccurate and non-standard term “e-cigarette smokers” was used throughout the article.

3. The authors referred to a question (“Do you still have COPD?”) that did not appear in the analyzed surveys.

4. The authors reversed two numbers in a flow chart describing important exclusions.

5. The authors failed to define “missing variables”.

These egregious errors should have been discovered and corrected by the authors, and by the journal’s reviewers and editors. Among the five authors is Pebbles Fagan, Ph.D., a former member of the FDA Tobacco Products Scientific Advisory Committee.

Dr. Orloff responded to my letter: “I should say I feel very embarrassed. Indeed this was sloppy on our side and we will fix and connect with the Editors in Chief on how to move forward.”

Still, the mess wasn’t immediately resolved. I downloaded the datasets from the U.S. government’s Behavioral Risk Factor Surveillance System (BRFSS).  But I was unable to reproduce the article’s study groups, the first basic step of any serious review. When Dr. Orloff disclosed further details of the analysis, I discovered that the authors had deleted 27,000 participants from the BRFSS data who had “ever” used an e-cigarette – even just one time – but did not use them at all at the time of the survey. This critical deletion was made without mention or explanation anywhere in the article. I advised Dr. Orloff that this large cohort should be classified as non-users of e-cigarettes, and the analysis should be re-run.

Dr. Orloff ended the correspondence shortly thereafter, around May 12.

Fast forward to the week of October 12, when the journal published a completely new version of the article, accompanied by the following statement: “The authors would like to express their apologies and regret for the errors in the original published version of the abovementioned article. The corrected article follows.”

The authors corrected their obvious errors, but failed to correct or add any reference to the 27,000 excluded ever vapers. Instead, they added the following brand new text to the discussion section to explain it away, as if it had been part of their research plan:

“Additionally, participants who reported having used e-cigarettes in their lifetime and currently do not use e-cigarettes (defined as former e-cigarette users) were excluded from the study population because of lack of clarity of exposure status and residual effects that have resulted from the e-cigarette derived chemical exposure which contribute to changes in the continuum of the disease progression leading to molecular changes detectable by biomarker analysis rather than reports. These former e-cigarette users have used e-cigarettes sometime in their entire life and have quit for different reasons. Studies have shown that while cessation of tobacco use diminishes the risk of experiencing long-term adverse health effects, past history of tobacco use is still associated with increased risk of lung diseases compared to never having smoked [citation here to a 1997 article ‘Smoking, alcohol consumption, and leukocyte counts.’]”

This explanation makes no sense. It is not valid to define someone who ever used an e-cigarette – even one time -- as a former user. The authors, post-hoc, unsuccessfully defended tossing out 27,000 ever vapers by inventing a “chemical exposure…leading to molecular changes… sometime in their entire life.”  But they kept in their study people who smoked up to 100 cigarettes – a far more toxic product. 

While Tobacco Induced Diseases inappropriately deleted the original article from their website, it is still available at the U.S. National Library of Medicine (here). I have also placed a copy of that original work here.

If the authors had adhered to professional standards, they would have acknowledged my major contributions in their corrective comments, but they did not.

I subsequently learned that Riccardo Polosa, a University of Catania (Italy) physician specializing in respiratory diseases, submitted a letter to the editor of Tobacco Induced Diseases, strongly questioning the validity of respiratory diseases in 18- to 24-year-old e-cigarette users. His letter was rejected.      

 

 

 

Monday, April 20, 2020

CDC’s Misuse of EVALI Misleads Americans That Smoking Safer Than Vaping

In a campaign of disinformation, culminating in the prolonged mischaracterization of the EVALI (e-cigarette, or vaping, associated lung injuries) crisis, the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has caused more Americans to believe the untruth that vaping is more dangerous than cigarette smoking.

Bentley University economist Dhaval Dave and colleagues at the City University of New York and Cornell have authored an article titled “News That Takes Your Breath Away: Risk Perceptions During an Outbreak of Vaping-Related Lung Injuries,” published by the National Bureau of Economic Research.  It analyzes the effect of actions taken by the CDC.

Dave et al. describe the federal response to EVALI: “Statements issued by the CDC during the early ‘crisis’ period were direct and clear suggesting that individuals should stop using all vaping products in the late summer of 2019.” (emphasis added). 

The CDC was silent on marijuana until December 10, 2019, when it acknowledged in a tweet that “products that contain THC, particularly from informal sources…play a major role in the current lung injury outbreak.”  The agency had delayed focusing public attention on cannabis products for over three months, as it was clear by early September to many observers, including me (here) and Boston University’s Dr. Michael Siegel (here), that the lung injuries were unrelated to nicotine-based e-cigarettes and vaping products which had been used by tens of millions of consumers for some 10 years with no serious lung problems.    

Figure 5 in Dave’s article, seen above, shows the effect of the anti-vaping misinformation campaign that has been supported since 2012 by the transfer of hundreds of millions of dollars from the FDA to the National Institutes of Health to cooperating university researchers.  This scheme has generated hundreds of laboratory and epidemiologic studies reporting exaggerated or downright false vaping harm. 

The chart shows the success of the misinformation campaign from 2012 to 2019.  The percentage of Americans viewing e-cigarettes as more harmful than cigarettes grew at a consistent rate of about two percentage points per year. 

The 2019 EVALI debacle took the public’s fear of nicotine e-cigarettes and vaping products to new heights.  As Dave et al. write, “the immediate impact…was to increase the fraction of respondents who perceived e-cigarettes as more harmful than smoking by about 16 percentage points.”  After the CDC issued its December 10 tweet emphasizing “the role of THC e-cigarette products, e-cigarette risk perceptions were partially revised downwards.”

That downward movement was minimal, as Figure 6 from the analysis illustrates:



Dave et al. generously refer to the CDC’s delayed identification of marijuana as the cause of EVALI as “precautionary” but they suggest that it may have had “unintended consequences. More targeted advice about the risks of THC e-cigarettes might have more effectively reduced the use of those products, potentially preventing EVALI cases. Moreover, the increase in e-cigarette risk perceptions might discourage adult smokers from using e-cigarettes…the increase in e-cigarette risk perceptions might slow the downward trend in youth smoking.”

By not announcing early on that contaminated marijuana products cause EVALI, the CDC increased the number of injuries and deaths.  The agency inaction also discouraged smokers from switching and might have even encouraged teens to smoke.